Review of George Baker, The Artwork Caught by the Tail : Francis Picabia and Dada in Paris, October Books/MIT, November 2007, and Francis Picabia, I Am a Beautiful Monster : Poetry, Prose, and Provocation, trans. by Marc Lowenthal, MIT, September 2007, at The Nation (05.11.2007) :
For Lowenthal--as for art historian George Baker, an editor at October who has written The Artwork Caught by the Tail,
an ambitious new study of Picabia's work "from the end of the First
World War to the beginnings of Surrealism in 1924"--all this is just
background. After all, Picabia's first publications date from 1917.
Moreover, Lowenthal dates Picabia's Dada years from 1919, and it is the
artist's relation to this movement, "one of the finest expressions of
nihilism in the twentieth century," that really counts for him. He
divides Picabia's production into pre-Dada, Dada and post-Dada phases.
Yet consider that Picabia, born in Paris in 1879, was 32 when he met
Duchamp, 37 when Dada first emerged at the Cabaret Voltaire in Zurich
in 1917, 38 when his first book of poems was published. Picabia was a
generation older than many of his fellow Dadaists, such as Tristan
Tzara (born in 1896), Marcel Janco (1895), Richard Huelsenbeck (1892)
and Hannah Höch (1889). So while the prevailing image of Dada as a
movement of angry young men (and a few women) in revolt against the
collective madness of the Great War is not wrong, it hardly describes
Picabia, who was already middle-aged when the war began and who escaped
it, like Duchamp, by decamping to New York. Whatever brought about the
massive change from his earlier conservatism, the motivations must have
been very different from those of a 20-year-old like Tzara.
In any case, a reading of Picabia's remarkable poetry suggests that
using Dada as a key to unlock it would be misleading at best. It may be
more than just a reluctance to cross the boundary between academic
disciplines that kept Baker, whose study comprises knotty but original
and often illuminating chapters on Dada drawing, Dada painting, Dada
photography, Dada abstraction, Dada cinema and Dada montage, from
attempting an analysis of Dada poetry as well, despite the fact that
his book covers the years when Picabia produced far more poetry than
art. It's as though Picabia's poetry was never quite Dada. And even as
far as art goes, Baker eventually has to entertain the possibility that
"Dada for Picabia had been one great detour."
Recent Comments